Compersion Isn't a Personality Trait, It's a Skill

This post accompanies Episode 6 of the Untamed Ember podcast, “Why You Can’t Force Compersion (The Nervous System Science of ENM).”

Your partner comes home glowing after a date.

They are talking faster than usual. Their whole face is doing that ridiculous newly-excited-person thing. They tell you about the restaurant, the flirting, the kiss in the parking lot, how much they like this person.

And maybe something warm happens inside you.

You smile without trying.

Their happiness feels good to witness.

Maybe you feel excited for them.

Maybe you feel affection toward the person who helped create that smile.

Maybe it is even erotic.

That experience has a name: compersion.

Or maybe your partner tells you exactly the same story and your stomach drops.

You feel jealous.

Left out.

Threatened.

Annoyed.

You genuinely want to be happy for them, but your nervous system appears to have missed the orientation meeting.

Then comes the dangerous conclusion:

Maybe I’m just not a compersive person.

That is where I want to interrupt.

Because compersion is often treated like a personality trait people either possess naturally or do not. Some people supposedly stroll into polyamory overflowing with delight about their partners loving other people, while everybody else gets assigned remedial jealousy homework.

The research is much messier than that.

People experience compersion differently. The conditions surrounding the relationship matter. Experience matters. Security matters. Self-worth, communication, feelings about a metamour, mindfulness, and emotional regulation may matter too.

And importantly, compersion and jealousy can exist at the same time.

So when I call compersion a skill, I do not mean you can perform three exercises every morning until your nervous system reliably produces delight on command.

Emotions do not take assignments that well.

I mean something more useful:

Compersion appears to be an emotional capacity that can be supported, practiced around, and made more accessible under certain conditions.

You cannot force the feeling.

You can build some of the conditions that give it somewhere to land.

Compersion Is Not Just “The Opposite of Jealousy”

Compersion is generally described as positive emotion in response to a partner’s other consensually non-monogamous relationships or intimate experiences.

That might include joy.

Contentment.

Excitement.

Pleasure.

Sometimes sexual arousal.

Researchers Flicker, Vaughan, and Meyers developed the COMPERSe measure specifically because the empirical literature had not had a standardized way to assess the experience. Their work conceptualized compersion across three areas: happiness about a partner’s relationship with a metamour, excitement about a partner forming new connections, and sexual arousal related to a partner’s other relationship.

Already, that tells us something important.

Compersion is not one single feeling.

You may experience one kind and not another.

You might feel genuinely happy that your partner loves someone while having absolutely no erotic interest in thinking about their sex life.

You might get excited when they have a promising first date but feel relatively neutral about an established metamour relationship.

You might feel deeply reassured knowing another person cares for your partner.

None of that requires fireworks.

And compersion does not need jealousy to vacate the premises before it can enter.

Balzarini and colleagues studied 3,530 polyamorous and 1,358 monogamous participants and found that jealousy and compersion were not simply opposite ends of one emotional continuum. People could experience positive and negative responses to a partner’s involvement with someone else simultaneously.

Which means:

I am happy for you

and

this is bringing something difficult up for me

can both be true.

That is not failed compersion.

That is emotional complexity.

The Pressure to Feel Compersion Can Ruin the Entire Point

Once compersion became popular language in polyamorous communities, it also acquired a strange moral glow.

Jealousy became the primitive emotion.

Compersion became the enlightened one.

And now we have people experiencing jealousy while performing enthusiasm because they think that is what “good poly” looks like.

That is not compersion.

That is customer service.

Your partner says:

“I had such an amazing time with them!”

And you produce:

“That’s SO GREAT!”

while every muscle from your jaw to your pelvic floor has quietly unionized.

Your body knows the difference.

Genuine positive emotion tends to have some quality of openness to it. Maybe there is warmth. Curiosity. Energy. Softness. A spontaneous smile. A little spark of pleasure at seeing somebody you care about happy.

Performed compersion tends to require monitoring.

Am I reacting correctly?

Do I look supportive enough?

Should I ask more questions?

Would a secure polyamorous person be happier than this?

Now you are no longer noticing your emotional experience.

You are grading it.

Compersion stops being joy and becomes proof of ideological competence.

No thank you.

Even People Who Experience Compersion Disagree About Whether It Is Learned

The research does not support a neat claim that everyone can simply learn compersion.

A 2022 qualitative study by Flicker, Thouin-Savard, and Vaughan asked 44 consensually non-monogamous participants who had already experienced compersion what helped or hindered the feeling.

That sample matters.

The researchers were not studying people who had never experienced compersion and teaching them how to develop it. They were asking people familiar with the emotion to describe the conditions surrounding it.

Participants themselves disagreed about whether compersion felt innate or learned.

So this is not where I announce:

SCIENCE PROVES COMPERSION IS A SKILL.

It does not.

What the research does suggest is that compersion is responsive to conditions.

And that makes the idea of cultivation much more interesting.

Because even if you have a natural tendency toward compersion, certain conditions may make it harder to access.

And even if compersion does not arrive easily for you, changing some of those conditions may make positive feelings more possible.

That is where the actual work lives.

Compersion Has a Hard Time Growing in Relational Scarcity

Think about the difference between these two situations.

Your relationship feels connected.

You have dependable time together.

Your partner follows through.

Your needs are being taken seriously.

You feel wanted.

Your partner begins dating someone new.

Now compare that with:

Your relationship has been disconnected for months.

Dates keep getting cancelled.

Sex has disappeared without conversation.

Your partner seems irritated whenever you ask for reassurance.

Then they begin dating someone new and suddenly have extraordinary amounts of time, energy, flirtation, sexual interest, and executive function.

And somebody tells you:

Try to feel compersion!

I would like to gently launch that suggestion into the sea.

In the 44-person qualitative study, participants commonly described self-worth, security in their relationship, having their needs met, communication with their partner, and positive feelings toward their metamour as factors that facilitated compersion.

That does not mean those conditions guarantee it.

The study was small, qualitative, and included only people who already knew what compersion felt like.

But the findings make relational sense.

It is easier to share in someone else’s abundance when your body does not believe their abundance is evidence of your deprivation.

Scarcity Is Often the Story Underneath the Story

A lot of us were trained on a relational equation that looks roughly like this:

If your partner wants someone else, you were insufficient.

If they are excited about someone else, you are becoming less exciting.

If another person becomes important, you become less important.

If they love someone else, there must now be less love available for you.

Relationship value becomes pie.

Every slice handed somewhere else looks suspiciously like it came off your plate.

You can intellectually reject that framework and still notice it appearing in your body.

Your partner says:

“I think I’m falling in love with them.”

Your beliefs say:

Love is not finite.

Your stomach says:

We have conducted an independent review and disagree.

This is one reason compersion is not produced by repeating abundance slogans at yourself.

If another relationship genuinely threatens something you need, positive feelings may be difficult.

And if the threat exists primarily in an old scarcity story, telling yourself not to feel it usually does not make the story disappear either.

The work is identifying which one you are dealing with.

Jealousy Does Not Have to Be Finished Before Compersion Begins

This is where I want to rescue people from a completely unnecessary project.

You do not need to eliminate jealousy before you are eligible for compersion.

Balzarini and colleagues found that people could anticipate both jealousy and compersion in response to a partner’s other romantic involvement. Their results also showed that people with actual experience of a partner engaging in outside romantic relationships anticipated more compersion and less jealousy than people without that experience.

Notice what that suggests.

Experience may matter.

Something that feels intensely threatening when it is hypothetical or new may feel different once your nervous system has lived through it and discovered:

My partner went on the date.

They came home.

Our relationship still exists.

They developed feelings.

I was not erased.

They had incredible sex.

We still had incredible sex.

Their relationship grew.

Mine did not automatically shrink.

These are not affirmations.

They are experiences.

And nervous systems learn from experience.

Sometimes the belief that there is room for both becomes easier to access after your body has actually survived evidence that there can be room for both.

Mindfulness May Matter, but Not Quite the Way Researchers Expected

A newer study gives us another useful piece.

In 2025, Clemons-Castaños and Flicker studied 122 polyamorous participants and examined jealousy and compersion in response to a partner’s New Relationship Energy.

Greater mindfulness was associated with greater compersion and lower jealousy.

For jealousy, the relationship was partly explained through better emotion regulation and greater distress tolerance.

But something especially interesting happened with compersion.

The researchers predicted that empathy would help explain the connection between mindfulness and compersion.

It did not.

That means we should be careful about telling a convenient story like:

Become more empathetic, then you will feel your partner’s happiness as your own.

The data did not support that pathway in this study.

We know mindfulness was associated with greater compersion.

We do not yet know exactly why.

And this was a cross-sectional study, so it cannot establish that practicing mindfulness causes people to become more compersive.

Still, the finding gives us an interesting possibility:

Perhaps being able to notice your internal experience without immediately becoming consumed by it creates more emotional room.

Not replacing jealousy.

Not bypassing fear.

Room.

Compersion Requires Enough Space for Another Feeling to Exist

Imagine your partner tells you they are wildly excited about someone.

If your entire system is consumed with:

What does this mean about me?

there is not much bandwidth left for:

What does this mean for them?

That does not make you selfish.

Threat narrows attention.

When something feels dangerous, your system naturally becomes interested in the danger.

Building capacity around jealousy may therefore create space for compersion indirectly.

Instead of:

I should be happier for them.

you might begin with:

What is happening in me right now?

My chest feels tight.

I am comparing myself.

I am afraid I am becoming less important.

Okay.

Can that experience get some attention first?

Maybe you need reassurance.

Maybe you need to reconnect.

Maybe you discover a real problem.

Maybe you just need enough time for your body to stop treating your partner’s excitement like breaking news about your imminent eviction.

When the alarm gets quieter, another feeling may become noticeable underneath it.

Sometimes that feeling is compersion.

Sometimes it is neutrality.

Neutrality is also allowed.

You Are Allowed to Feel Absolutely Nothing

This deserves its own section because the compersion conversation often forgets it.

You do not owe anyone positive emotion about their other relationships.

You can be perfectly supportive and feel:

Cool. Hope you had fun. What are we doing for dinner?

There is nothing deficient about that.

Your partner’s relationship belongs to them.

You do not need to become emotionally invested in every romantic development occurring somewhere in the polycule.

You also do not need to adore your metamour.

Compersion is not a relationship requirement.

Ethical behavior is.

You can honor agreements.

Respect autonomy.

Treat metamours decently.

Communicate honestly.

Support a partner’s freedom to build other relationships.

And never once experience a rush of joy when they leave for a date.

There is no compersion merit badge.

Your Relationship With the Metamour Can Matter

Compersion is often discussed as though it happens only between you and your partner.

But the metamour is part of the emotional picture too.

In the Flicker, Thouin-Savard, and Vaughan qualitative study, positive regard for a metamour was among the factors participants frequently described as facilitating compersion.

Again, that does not mean you must become friends.

Parallel polyamory exists.

Some people genuinely function better with less contact.

But it is worth noticing how the person themselves affects the emotional experience.

It may be easier to feel happy about your partner’s relationship when you believe the other person treats them beautifully.

When you trust their intentions.

When you have seen kindness.

When they do not seem to regard you as an obstacle.

When the relationship feels less like a mysterious threat-shaped shadow and more like an actual human connection involving people you understand.

Sometimes familiarity reduces scarcity.

Sometimes it absolutely does not.

Your mileage may vary spectacularly.

Stop Using Compersion to Avoid Jealousy

There is also a sneaky form of bypassing that looks very progressive.

Instead of working with jealousy, someone races toward compersion.

“I’m going to focus on how happy I am for them.”

That might be genuine.

Or it might be a way of refusing to acknowledge:

I am scared.

I need reassurance.

I feel neglected.

Something about this arrangement is hurting me.

The existence of compersion does not make those experiences less legitimate.

Remember, research suggests jealousy and compersion can coexist rather than functioning as mutually exclusive states.

So you do not have to choose the nicer emotion and evict the inconvenient one.

Sometimes mature emotional regulation sounds like:

I am genuinely thrilled for you, and I am having a hard time tonight.

That sentence has room for both people.

What Cultivating Compersion Can Actually Look Like

If you want more access to compersion, I would not start by trying to manufacture happiness.

Start with conditions.

Notice what happens when your partner shares something positive about another relationship.

What occurs first in your body?

Do you soften?

Brace?

Go numb?

Feel curious?

Start comparing?

Do you immediately need details?

Do you want no details at all?

There is information there.

Then look at the relationship itself.

Do you feel secure?

Are your needs being discussed?

Do you have enough connection?

Can you ask for reassurance without shame?

Does your partner’s New Relationship Energy repeatedly leave you carrying all the boring responsibilities while they float around like a teenager who has just discovered texting?

Compersion cannot repair inequity.

Next, notice the stories.

If your partner has an amazing sexual experience, what does your mind make it mean?

That you are sexually inadequate?

That they will prefer the other person?

That uniqueness requires exclusivity?

You do not have to immediately replace those thoughts with more enlightened ones.

Just stop allowing them to masquerade as objective facts.

And then practice letting your partner’s joy belong to them.

Not as evidence about you.

Not as a ranking.

Not as a referendum on your relationship.

Just:

Someone I love experienced something wonderful.

See what happens.

Genuine Compersion Usually Doesn’t Need an Audience

There is something else I want you to notice.

Performed compersion is often loud.

It wants evidence.

Look how happy I am!

Tell me more!

I am SO excited for you!

Genuine compersion may be much quieter.

Your partner is getting ready for a date and you notice that they look fantastic.

You help them choose earrings.

You feel a little warmth watching them bounce around the bathroom.

They leave.

You go back to your book.

That counts.

Or your partner tells you that their metamour got the job they desperately wanted and you immediately think:

That’s fucking great. I know how worried they were.

That counts too.

Or you see your partner being loved well by someone else and something in your body settles because you know they have another person who shows up for them.

That can be compersion.

The feeling does not have to be dramatic to be real.

Compersion Is Not Evidence That You Have Transcended Jealousy

The point of cultivating compersion is not to graduate from one emotion into another.

It is to increase emotional possibility.

Research is still young here.

The strongest qualitative study of facilitating factors included only 44 people who already experienced compersion. The newer mindfulness study involved 122 polyamorous adults and found associations, not proof of causation. Researchers are still actively working out what compersion is, how best to measure it, and why some people experience it more easily than others.

So we should resist turning a developing research area into another rigid relationship doctrine.

What we know so far is much more humane.

People can experience jealousy and compersion together.

People with actual experience of partners having other relationships may anticipate more compersion than people without that experience.

People who have experienced compersion describe security, having needs met, self-worth, communication, and positive metamour relationships as helpful conditions.

Mindfulness is associated with greater compersion, although we do not yet know exactly what mechanism explains that relationship.

That does not sound like a fixed personality trait.

It sounds like an emotion living inside a relational ecosystem.

You Don’t Have to Force the Spark

Maybe compersion comes easily to you.

Maybe it arrives only sometimes.

Maybe you can feel it with one partner and not another.

Maybe you feel it around romantic relationships but not sexual ones.

Maybe you feel it after the relationship becomes established but absolutely not during New Relationship Energy.

Maybe you mostly experience neutrality.

None of those responses tell me whether you are good at polyamory.

The more interesting question is what happens when your partner’s joy with someone else enters the room.

Does your body immediately brace because you learned that someone else gaining means you are losing?

Can you notice that reaction without shaming it?

Can you build enough security that another person’s pleasure no longer has to function as evidence against your own importance?

Can jealousy have somewhere to go besides control?

Can your partner’s happiness eventually become something you are free to enjoy rather than something you are required to perform?

That is what I mean when I call compersion a skill.

Not a feeling you can command.

Not a test you can pass.

A capacity you can make more room for.

Sometimes that room fills with joy.

Sometimes it fills with jealousy first.

Sometimes nothing much happens at all.

But when the warmth does show up, you do not have to squeeze it into existence.

You notice your partner smiling.

Something in you softens.

And their happiness gets to be good news without your body automatically translating it into bad news about you.

Listen to Episode 6

This article accompanies Episode 6 of the Untamed Ember podcast, “Why You Can’t Force Compersion (The Nervous System Science of ENM).”

References

Balzarini, R. N., McDonald, J. N., Kohut, T., Lehmiller, J. J., Holmes, B. M., & Harman, J. J. (2021). Compersion: When jealousy-inducing situations don’t (just) induce jealousy. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 50(4), 1311–1324.https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-020-01853-1

Clemons-Castaños, C. R., & Flicker, S. M. (2025). Polyamorous individuals’ jealous and compersive responses to their partner’s new relationship energy: The role of mindfulness, emotion regulation, distress tolerance, and empathy. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 51(4), e70068.https://doi.org/10.1111/jmft.70068

Flicker, S. M., Thouin-Savard, M. I., & Vaughan, M. D. (2022). Factors that facilitate and hinder the experience of compersion among individuals in consensually non-monogamous relationships. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 51(6), 3035–3048.https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-022-02333-4

Flicker, S. M., Vaughan, M. D., & Meyers, L. S. (2021). Feeling good about your partners’ relationships: Compersion in consensually non-monogamous relationships. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 50(4), 1569–1585.https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-021-01985-y

Untamed Ember®

More conversations about sex, relationships, nervous systems, and the conditioning we didn’t choose:

untamedember.comuntamedember.kit.com

For information about therapy and clinical services:

flowarttherapy.com

Dr. Misty is clinically licensed to provide therapy to clients located in Washington state, Maryland, Virginia, and Washington, D.C.

Dr. Misty Gibson

Dr. Misty Gibson is a business owner, author, entrepreneur, certified sex therapist, and an educator. She is passionate about mental health for neurodivergent and queer folx, and encouraging a sex-positive atmosphere within relationships.

https://untamedember.com
Next
Next

Your Attachment Style Didn't Disappear Just Because You're Poly